After a disappointing defeat in the desert, a huge debate has erupted concerning Gareth Southgate's position as England manager. Some people value his tenure as a success, whereas others believe it is time for the nation to finally raise their expectations, seeing nothing less than a tournament win as enough.
'Southgate in' or 'Southgate out'?
Southgate in!
Southgate out!
The England boss has added to the uncertainty himself, saying that he needs "a bit of time to reflect" and that the decision making process "needs a bit of time to make sure everybody makes the right decision". However, as England's second most successful manager ever, I believe Southgate should be entitled to more time, here's why:
Southgate's Tournament Record
The former England defender has led the national team into three major tournaments, the 2018 and 2022 World Cups, as well as the covid affected European Championships, eventually played in 2021.
In these three tournaments, Gareth has taken the Three Lions to their first World Cup semi-final since 1990, their first major tournament final since their infamous triumph in 1966, and a quarter-final, where they were narrowly defeated by the reigning world champions. Yet, with the overall dissatisfaction around the country regarding Southgate's performances, you would be unable to recognise the consistent success he has provided.
It seems to me that the average English football fan does not understand how difficult it is to win a major international tournament, and therefore don't give enough praise to the management team. To compare his achievements, below is Sir Bobby Robson's finishes in major tournaments.
World Cup:
1986 - Quarter-Final
1990 - Fourth place
European Championship:
1984 - Did not qualify
1988 - Group stage
Sir Bobby is widely regarded as the greatest English manager of all time, and he had some remarkable talent at his disposal during his time as England manager. Already, with a young and inexperienced side, Gareth has managed to match his record at World Cup's, while drastically surpassing his record at European Championships. Perhaps Southgate isn't doing too badly after all...
Who would replace him?
If Southgate was to leave, the FA would have to find a replacement; let's evaluate some of the favourites.
Mauricio Pochettino
The Argentine currently sits at 4/1 to become the next England manager - the clear favourite. He would provide England with an attacking mentality, exciting football and a lot of goals, but how sustainable is that approach in tournament football?
By looking at this year's four semi-finalists, you will see that a sense of pragmatism is crucial if you want to succeed in international tournaments. Is a manager who has never taken charge of a national team, a manager who is trophyless in England the man for the job, just because he plays attacking football?
Yes, excitement may sometimes be lacking under Southgate, however, he provides the team with a sense of security. After all, he was a penalty shootout away from a winner's medal.
Eddie Howe
Placed at 10/1, the bookies see Eddie Howe as the most likely Englishman to take over from Southgate. The Newcastle manager has a very distinct game plan, an attractive style and an incredible ability to improve players that he works with - the transformation of Joelinton is one of the great footballing stories in recent times.
However, a lot of preparation and training is needed to implement such a tactically precise game plan. Would breaks of only two or three weeks be enough time for Eddie to be effective? Several parties have suggested that his training methods are demanding and intense, which would not suit the international time-table.
All this being said, is his appointment realistic? Flying high in the Premier League and adored in the north-east, would Howe even consider taking the job?
Where would you rather manage?
Newcastle, bring me the money!
England, for the whole country!
The feelings of heartbreak are rife across the country at the moment, as expected, and cries for Southgate to be sacked are as loud as they have ever been. Admittedly, a Quarter-Final does feel somewhat underwhelming, but it does not warrant Southgate's departure.
Southgate's influence can be seen in the morale, the togetherness and the fight of this current crop of players. Never before has an England team had the ability to throw club rivalries out of the window and perform at such a high level as a collective.
Some may argue that he's out of his depth tactically, however, Gareth's prowess in man management and his ability to motivate the squad make up for whatever he lacks in tactical knowledge.
He might be replaced. He might not manage another game for England. I truly believe, however, that if England are to win a major trophy with this 'golden generation', Gareth Southgate is the right man to lead them. Let us know your thoughts in the comments.
Comments